Janet Fraser: dead baby not as traumatic as birth rape


You might think that freebirth advocate Janet Fraser would be chastened by the death of her baby at homebirth. You’d be wrong. In fact, according to Fraser, it wasn’t even traumatic.

My birthrape with my first child is traumatic. My stillbirth was not.

Fraser is the premier Australian advocate of unassisted childbirth (UC) also known as freebirth. That’s right, a birth unattended by any medical professional of any kind, no matter how poorly educated. And Fraser added an extra fillip, no prenatal care of any kind. As she went into the labor that eventually resulted in a dead baby, she actually gave an interview to an Australian newspaper on March 22,2009 in which she boasted of her choices:

Janet Fraser is in labour… Has she called the hospital to let them know what’s happening? “When you go on a skiing trip, do you call the hospital to say, ‘I’m coming down the mountain, can you set aside a spot for me in the emergency room?’ I don’t think so,” says Fraser, whose breathing sounds strained…

… She hasn’t seen a doctor or any health professional since becoming pregnant this time. No ultrasound, no genetic testing, no internal examinations, no stethoscope. Does she have any feeling for how long the labour will go? “I could do this for days. My daughter’s birth was 50-something hours. You just do it — it’s just birth, a normal physiological process.”

The baby was not born for another five days. The death was described in another newspaper report:

… [T]he natural water birth of her third child, a girl, at her home went horribly wrong in the early hours of March 27.

Ambulances were sent to the address following a triple-0 call made at 1.13am.

An ambulance service spokesman said paramedics were called to a Croydon Park address for a newborn baby who had suffered cardiac arrest and was not breathing.

Paramedics failed to revive the baby throughout the journey to the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital at Camperdown.

“They were basically working on the baby all the way to the hospital,” the spokesman said.

It boggles the mind that Fraser could describe the death of her daughter as less traumatic than the live birth of her son, but evidently “having it your way” is much more important than having a live baby.

Fraser may not have been traumatized by her daughter’s death, perhaps a coroner’s inquest will change that. Fraser, like Australian homebirth midwife Lisa Barrett, has tried to argue that her irresponsibility led to a stillbirth, not a live birth, and therefore it should not be investigated. The New South Wales police investigators disagree:

A Coronial inquest will be held into the controversial death of a baby girl during a home birth where doctors or midwives were banned from assisting a delivery – a practice known as “free-birthing”.

The inquest comes two years after initial confusion as to whether the baby took a breath after delivery or died in utero. The latter instance would have prevented a coronial inquiry.

The Sunday Age understands New South Wales police have conducted an extensive investigation to present a brief of evidence to the coroner.

The matter is listed as a mention in the Glebe Coroner’s Court on March 18, almost two years to the day the controversy broke.

Presumably, Fraser is going to claim that her daughter was dead at the moment of birth. No one thought so at the time. Someone at Fraser’s house requested an ambulance and EMTs performed CPR all the way to the hospital.

Fraser may not have been personally traumatized birth the death of her daughter, but she certainly recognized that the death could have a traumatizing effect on others. Therefore, she deleted the story from her freebirth message board, Joyous Birth. Deaths are so very, very inconvenient when you are trying to pretend that irresponsible choices are safe. Better to obliterate all mention of it.

It’s hard to imagine anything more selfish and self absorbed than choosing freebirth, but Janet Fraser has topped that with something even more reprehensible. There’s nothing uglier than trying to erase all mention of your dead child and declaring that the death wasn’t that traumatic at all. Fortunately, the coroner is not going to let her get away with it.

8 Responses to “Janet Fraser: dead baby not as traumatic as birth rape”

  1. Angie
    May 22, 2016 at 5:30 pm #

    A small number of us know what really occurred and who was really present. Some people shouldn’t throw stones, Janet. You never know what might bounce back at you eventually… especially when you attack people without provocation and destroy their lives by releasing your hounds. I wonder if it’s too late to call the coroner? Or are you ready to apologise?

  2. Erin
    December 8, 2015 at 7:38 pm #

    Self-delusion to a mind-boggling extent. Or, at the very least, narcissism so blatant, I worry for the other children in her care if mommy is such a self-absorbed snowflake. As a 34 week loss mom, I cannot fathom such indifference to the death of a child…unless getting pregnant was never about the child to begin with…

  3. Nathalie
    April 30, 2015 at 5:26 am #

    I lost a pragnancy in the 8th week and one in the 12th week. Technically there weren’t even babies, the doctor never found a heartbeat. But I was traumatised and shocked! My 3rd baby was a planned C-section after two previous C-sections. I almost died after this 3rd C-section, lost a lot of blood, had to be opened again, was separated from my baby for 3 days to recover … the doctors didn’t really find a reason why it happened…. I was traumatised… and happy about my Baby being well!!! If it had been the other way round, me well and my baby in mortal danger… I can not even think about such a situation! Thank you Dr. Tuteur for this page. Until now I thought I had missed something, as I had no “real” birth. But in fact I should be happy to be alive and to have 3 healthy kids, that I really love, even without a natural birth. So what the hell. Thank you! And many thanks to my obstetrician who, yes, fortunately is a surgeon and knew how to save my live!

    • Krista
      December 8, 2015 at 10:26 pm #

      “Happy to have 3 healthy kids that I love, even without a natural birth.”

      It saddens me that there are women on this planet who have been lied to about NCB and thus have trouble bonding with their kids just because they needed life-saving interventions.

  4. n
    April 25, 2015 at 7:07 am #

    I just cannot believe it…I mean I can but I’m just staggered. I suffered a stillbirth at 5 months pregnant (technically a late miscarriage, but I describe it as a stillbirth because of labouring and birthing the baby) and it was the most painful, traumatic event of my life. And I knew my baby had died in utero when I was labouring…I suffered from PTSD throughout my subsequent pregnancy. I’m afraid I just do not believe this woman when she says loosing her child in this was was not traumatic. I feel deeply sorry for her – as she must be either seriously delusional or so traumatised she has totally disassociated. I feel even more sorry for her child who never had a chance at life.

  5. korn75
    March 4, 2015 at 7:34 pm #

    What a selfish, ignorant, spoiled bitch. It wasn’t about her, it should have always been about the baby. And now because of her selfishness, that child will have no life to live. What a selfish bitch. 100 years ago, infant mortality was relatively high. Because of modern medicine, its very low. She should be charged in this child’s death. There’s responsible choice. Then there’s irresponsible, stupid choice that leads to the death of another human life. Some also refer to this as manslaughter


  1. Ervin Sammut - March 26, 2013

    Fantastic websites…

    some time to go through or check out the articles and other content or web pages we’ve related to under the…

  2. Abraham Yerry - March 25, 2013

    Gems with the web-based…

    very couple of internet sites that happen to generally be in-depth beneath, from our perspective are unquestionably properly truly worth checking out…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.