Dr. Amy in breastfeeding debate on WBUR

Breastfeeding activists in my state, Massachusetts, are celebrating a ban on formula gift bags for new mothers.

That’s right: a group of women who will never use formula are patting themselves on the back for taking away a gift of free formula from women who might use it. And what do those who might use the formula think of the ban? Don’t be silly! No one asked them.

Who cares what those women think? Apparently women who aren’t wholeheartedly committed to exclusive breastfeeding aren’t even worthy of being included in the conversation. The fact that the lactivists are almost exclusively Western, white, privileged women and the women who they have deprived of free formula are much more likely to be women of color or poor women is simply an unfortunate coincidence.

No one asked those women, but I tried to speak for them when I participated in a debate on WBUR, the local National Public Radio affiliate. Dr. Bobbi Philipp, professor of pediatrics at director of the newborn nursery at Boston University School of Medicine, and one of the activists behind the ban.

You can listen to the debate below.

In preparation for the radio show I reviewed the meager existing literature on banning formula gift bags and didn’t find any evidence that it actually increases rates of breastfeeding. I did find, remarkably, that not a single study asked women whether the gift bags influence in any way their decision to breastfeed. This is consistent with a deeply disturbing set of assumptions that seems to be taken for granted among lactivists:

1. Women who have not committed to exclusive breastfeeding in advance must be manipulated to embark upon exclusive breastfeeding.

2. Women are not reflective individuals capable of making life decisions on their own.

3. Women are so shallow that they will be swayed in one direction or another by a free gift; therefore, their “betters” must make sure that they aren’t corrupted by free gifts.

4. Women’s opinions and desires are irrelevant so there is no point in asking those who are affected by a ban what they think of the ban.

5. These is no reason to ask women whether they want to breastfeed because there is no legitimate reason for not wanting to breastfeed.

6. Women are treated merely as instrumental. How breastfeeding impacts them as individuals with individual needs, desires and constraints is irrelevant.

I don’t think of myself as a naive person, but I still shocked that a group of privileged relatively well off white women have such obviously demeaning views of women other than themselves. Although I am an enthusiastic proponent of breastfeeding, and enthusiastically embraced breastfeeding my own children, I recognize that what worked for me and my family is not necessarily right for all other women and their families.

Rather than patting themselves on the back for engineering a ban on formula gifts bags, Massachusetts lactivists should be embarrassed by their modern day version of noblesse oblige. They are not the nobility of the mothering world and they are not obliged (or even entitled) to manipulate other women into making the “right” decision on infant feeding.

9 Responses to “Dr. Amy in breastfeeding debate on WBUR”

  1. Joey
    March 6, 2015 at 3:21 am #

    Some women want to breast feed, some would rather formula feed. And the whole world needs to get over it and on with it. It really is as simple as that.

  2. Lizz
    June 10, 2013 at 1:52 am #

    Are these women really that bad at saying no to an ad with a free gift? Also if I give you the address to the Provo Utah WIC and show you all the posters especially the lactation consultant’s office(which you have to visit before they will let you quit). Now stare at that poster of the abandoned baby toys talking about breastfeeding reducing SIDS, the baby in the dunce cap talking about lost IQ points, finally end on one saying “Breastfeeding love in liquid form”.
    Finally go to a local hospital and tell them that your not breastfeeding for a reason like medication they will give you 2 pamphlets on breastfeeding, offer breastfeeding education with the lactation consultant and still lecture you about breastfeeding even though it would mean going off your in my case anti-psychotics. It’s in my chart that I had postpartum psychosis and that I’m heavily medicated to avoid a repeat but it still gets shoved down your throat. Worse you get the one nurse who brings up that breastfeeding is supposed to help postpartum depression and beats that point to death.

    I understand that culture is different in different states and in your’s there may actually be a formula feeding culture but not all of us do.

    Also a majority of mothers on WIC are working women who may not have jobs that work with pumping, You should also know that except for the brand spanking new target line, store brand most formulas only have a regular milk, soy and maybe a sensitive. Similac and Enfamil have enough selection to fit people’s needs but many women use store brand formula when they run out of formula for the month.


  1. sagame - November 18, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Information to that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/07/dr-amy-in-breastfeeding-debate-on-wbur.html […]

  2. dewaqq online - November 8, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here to that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/07/dr-amy-in-breastfeeding-debate-on-wbur.html […]

  3. electronics mystery box sale - August 31, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Here you will find 10575 more Information on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/07/dr-amy-in-breastfeeding-debate-on-wbur.html […]

  4. Dr Oz Garcinia Cambogia Review - February 16, 2013


    […]the time to read or take a look at the content or internet sites we have linked to below the[…]…

  5. hair loss cure - February 16, 2013


    […]very handful of internet sites that take place to be detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly properly worth checking out[…]…

  6. games yepi - February 15, 2013


    […]we came across a cool site which you may love. Take a search if you want[…]…

  7. learn - February 15, 2013


    […]The details mentioned within the write-up are several of the top obtainable […]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.