Penny Simkin, hypocrite

Natural childbirth advocates have been caught, proverbially, with their pants down. After making the specter of posttraumatic stress disorder a centerpiece of their efforts to promote natural childbirth, they are shocked to discover that it is natural childbirth itself that may cause post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) after birth.

Hypocrites take your mark! Set! Go!

The first hypocrite around the bend is Penny Simkin, physical therapist, childbirth educator and all around popularizer of the notion that modern obstetrics causes PTSD and natural childbirth prevents it.

Not surprisingly, she is now struggling mightily to discredit a new study that claims that unmedicated childbirth is a cause of posttraumatic stress disorder after birth. Step 1: discredit the paper.

The paper is Postpartum Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms: The Uninvited Birth Companion. The impact of pain on symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder is just one of many findings noted in the study:

The prevalence of post-partum PTSD was 3.4% (complete PTSD), 7.9% nearly complete PTSD, and 25.9% significant partial disorder. Women who developed PTSD symptoms had a higher prevalence of “traumatic” previous childbirth, with subsequent depression and anxiety. They also reported more medical complications and “mental crises” during pregnancy as well as anticipating more childbirth pain and fear. Instrumental or cesarean deliveries were not associated with PTSD. Most of the women who developed PTSD symptoms delivered vaginally, but received fewer analgesics with stronger reported pain. Women with PTSD reported more discomfort with the undressed state, stronger feelings of danger, and higher rates of not wanting additional children.

None of these findings is unexpected. Indeed, there is a substantial amount of research suggesting that labor pain can be a source of trauma:

It has been suggested that the intense experience of pain can lead to an event perceived as traumatic. In their study of individuals injured in traumatic events, Schreiber and Galai found that the sensation of pain rather than the injury
itself caused the perception of a traumatic event. Melzack reported that the experience of pain in childbirth is associated with traumatic memories long after the birth itself, with others reporting that many prefer to have the next birth by cesarean
section due to the memory of painful childbirth even 3 years after the birth [6]. In a survey of 28 women requesting cesarean section, all had memories of a traumatic birth, including 50% who had an emergency cesarean section. The repercussions of post-traumatic symptoms after childbirth are varied, with some reporting avoidance of sex and fear of having further children.

Simkin is already on record insisting that it is “suffering” not pain that leads to PTSD.

She discounts the benefit of pain relief in labor:

An enormous industry exists in North America to manufacture and safely deliver pain relieving medications for labor. Hospital maternity departments are designed with elimination of pain as a primary consideration, complete with numerous interventions and protocols to keep the pain management medications from causing serious harm. When staff believe that labor pain equals suffering, they convey that belief to the woman and her partner, and, instead of offering support and guidance for comfort, they offer pain medication…

What an amazing coincidence that Simkin disparages the service that she is incapable of providing (pharmacologic pain relief) and instead offers the service that she can charge money for (doula services).

For Simkin, the implication is straight forward. Pain does not cause PTSD. Therefore, anesthesiologists cannot prevent PTSD. It is “suffering” that causes PTSD and doulas can relieve “suffering.”

And what is suffering?

Simkin insists that it is “suffering” that leads to PTSD and suffering is whatever the sufferer says it is:

One’s perception of the event is what defines it as traumatic or not. As it pertains to childbirth, “Birth trauma is in the eye of the beholder”, and whether others would agree is irrelevant to the diagnosis.

Unless, of course, the beholder says it is unrelieved pain that is traumatic.

That’s why Simkin is trying to discredit the new paper. The study found that untreated pain is among a variety of factors associated with PTSD after childbirth:

There were more natural births (noninterventional) in the PTSD group than in the control group. A significantly smaller number of women who developed PTSD symptoms received analgesia during delivery compared to the control group (chi-square P = 0.000).

Moreover, the extent to which women were supported during labor made no difference:

No relationship was found between the development of PTSD symptoms after childbirth and being accompanied by someone during labor or the extent to which the accompanying person gave support.

But, but, but … these results are unacceptable. Simkin insists that the paper actually showed that the etiology of PTSD after childbirth is complex and multi-factorial:

Furthermore, these women had numerous other factors that are associated with PTSD. Before accepting natural birth as the major cause of PTSD after childbirth, please check the … other factors, which were as prevalent, or nearly so, as lack of pain relief as a cause of PTSD… [F]or example, 80 percent of the women with PTSD also had discomfort with being undressed; previous mental health problems in previous pregnancy or postpartum; and complications, emotional crises, and high fear of childbirth in their current pregnancy. All these factors have been reported in many studies to be instrumental in the development of PTSD.

Yes, all these factors have been reported to be involved in the development of PTSD, suggesting that characteristics of the women who develop PTSD are more important than their actual experience in labor or their perception of what caused the trauma. Trauma isn’t in the eyes of the beholder, it’s in the psychological disposition of the beholder.

Hence the hypocrisy. The papers that Simkin has cited for years in her assertion that it is the modern obstetric experience that leads to PTSD found exactly the same thing that this new paper found: that PTSD reflects the predisposition of the patient, not her experience. Simkin ignored those findings and insisted that childbirth educators and doulas could prevent PTSD by changing a woman’s experience by:

  • Recommend that the woman/couple learn about labor, maternity care practices, and master coping techniques for labor…
  • Recommend a Birth Plan…
  • [A] process in which she was respected, nurtured, and aided…
  • [N]o supportive person wants a woman to have pain medication that she had hoped to avoid. A previously agreed-upon “code word” provides a safety net for a woman who is highly motivated to have an unmedicated birth.

Simkin can’t have it both ways. Either the etiology of PTSD after childbirth is complex, multi-factorial, and affected by psychological predisposition or it isn’t.

I happen to think she is right that this is precisely what the new paper shows, but it is also precisely what everything else she has been citing in support of her own theories shows. PTSD after childbirth has more to do with the patient than her experience. Hence we cannot conclude that unmedicated childbirth leads to PTSD, but we also cannot conclude that a poor childbirth experience leads to PTSD or that childbirth educators and doulas can prevent it.

108 Responses to “Penny Simkin, hypocrite”

  1. Sara
    June 15, 2014 at 8:43 am #

    I personally know woman with 5 kids who had both vaginal (no major complications) and c sections and preferred c sections. I’ve also heard of this preference anecdotally in various online forums, opinion articles, etc. Not my preference, but I know that some women do prefer c/s.

  2. January 5, 2014 at 10:00 pm #

    Ugh I wish I had known this before I had my baby. It makes sense to me. The pain made all the other things that happened so much worse, I felt like I was being kicked while I was down, and it was really hard to think things through when you only had a few minutes between contractions to do so. I remember giving up and watching a clock in the nursery for hours, silently dealing with the pain. It was awful.

  3. Tammy
    June 27, 2013 at 7:30 pm #

    As a chapter leader for a local ICAN chapter and local Birth Worker, I have to question the validity of the study. I have met very very women that had a respectful labor and birth talk about PPD or PTSD. It’s the women that had traumatic births, c-sections and instrumental deliveries that come away with the trauma and depression. It takes years to work out their feelings. I cannot see, working with such women, how this study can make claims that are completely the opposite of what I see every day.

    • Amy Tuteur, MD
      June 27, 2013 at 8:23 pm #

      As an ICAN leader, don’t you meet only women who have had previous C-sections?

      • Sarah
        January 29, 2014 at 4:45 pm #

        ICAN leaders can meet a variety of people. Have you only met women who birthed vaginally?

        You’ll notice also that she said respectful labor and birth. A cesarean delivery doesn’t necessarily equate to disrespectful labor and birth, although it could.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. cheap but top shelf cannabis online - October 17, 2021

    cheap but top shelf cannabis online

    […]here are some hyperlinks to websites that we link to simply because we consider they are really worth visiting[…]

  2. background check website - October 17, 2021

    background check website

    […]the time to study or pay a visit to the content or web pages we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  3. magic mushrooms - October 15, 2021

    magic mushrooms

  4. stiiizy battery alternative Archives - October 14, 2021

    stiiizy battery alternative Archives

    […]that may be the end of this report. Here you will locate some internet sites that we feel you will value, just click the links over[…]

  5. magic mushrooms - October 14, 2021

    magic mushrooms

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  6. buy pentobarbital - October 14, 2021

    buy pentobarbital

  7. taurus pt92 for sale - October 14, 2021

    taurus pt92 for sale

  8. deckmate shuffler - October 14, 2021

    deckmate shuffler

    […]check below, are some entirely unrelated sites to ours, even so, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  9. sig m18 for sale - October 13, 2021

    sig m18 for sale

    […]although web-sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they may be in fact worth a go by way of, so have a look[…]

  10. taurus 454 raging bull - October 13, 2021

    taurus 454 raging bull

    […]Here is a great Blog You might Discover Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  11. remington v3 realtree timber - October 13, 2021

    remington v3 realtree timber

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you may get pleasure from. Take a appear if you want[…]

  12. PUFF BAR THC - October 12, 2021

    PUFF BAR THC

    […]Here is a good Blog You may Uncover Intriguing that we Encourage You[…]

  13. lowes kronos server - October 7, 2021

    lowes kronos server

  14. sajtovi - October 7, 2021

    sajtovi

    Izrada web sajtova, mobilnih aplikacija, portala i internet prodavnica

  15. aromatherapy for anxiety - October 3, 2021

    aromatherapy for anxiety

    […]always a massive fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but do not get a good deal of link like from[…]

  16. ارقام بنات - October 3, 2021

    ارقام بنات

    […]The data mentioned in the write-up are some of the very best available […]

  17. shipping containers for sale - October 2, 2021

    shipping containers for sale

    […]here are some links to web sites that we link to due to the fact we feel they may be really worth visiting[…]

  18. FARMING EQUIPMENT FOR SALE IN GAUTENG - October 2, 2021

    FARMING EQUIPMENT FOR SALE IN GAUTENG

    […]check below, are some entirely unrelated internet sites to ours, having said that, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  19. Rwanda Gorilla Tour - October 1, 2021

    Rwanda Gorilla Tour

    […]just beneath, are quite a few completely not connected internet sites to ours, having said that, they may be certainly worth going over[…]

  20. Macbook akku schnell leer schmerikon - October 1, 2021

    Macbook akku schnell leer schmerikon

    […]please take a look at the web pages we follow, such as this one particular, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  21. Kenya safari holiday deals - September 30, 2021

    Kenya safari holiday deals

    […]always a large fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but do not get lots of link really like from[…]

  22. GOLF CARTS FOR SALE - September 30, 2021

    GOLF CARTS FOR SALE

    […]just beneath, are several completely not connected web sites to ours, nevertheless, they’re surely really worth going over[…]

  23. Mac akku service bubikon - September 30, 2021

    Mac akku service bubikon

    […]please check out the web-sites we stick to, which includes this 1, as it represents our picks in the web[…]

  24. Sig Sauer Handguns - September 27, 2021

    Sig Sauer Handguns

    […]just beneath, are many completely not related websites to ours, nevertheless, they may be certainly really worth going over[…]

  25. Computer Repair Bridgewater - September 27, 2021

    Computer Repair Bridgewater

  26. Weebi agence de communication - September 27, 2021

    Weebi agence de communication

    […]The information and facts mentioned inside the write-up are a number of the top offered […]

  27. sugar gliders for sale near me - September 26, 2021

    sugar gliders for sale near me

    […]Every when in a while we decide on blogs that we read. Listed below would be the most recent websites that we decide on […]

  28. free mp3 - September 25, 2021

    free mp3

    […]the time to study or stop by the material or web-sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  29. pc software full download - September 24, 2021

    pc software full download

    […]the time to study or take a look at the subject material or websites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  30. free download for windows 7 - September 24, 2021

    free download for windows 7

    […]one of our guests a short while ago proposed the following website[…]

  31. free app download for windows 10 - September 23, 2021

    free app download for windows 10

    […]just beneath, are several completely not connected sites to ours, nonetheless, they’re surely really worth going over[…]

  32. free download for windows pc - September 23, 2021

    free download for windows pc

    […]below you will locate the link to some websites that we consider you’ll want to visit[…]

  33. بديل تروكولر - September 23, 2021

    بديل تروكولر

    […]the time to study or pay a visit to the material or internet sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  34. projektownie wnętrz Gdynia - September 22, 2021

    projektownie wnętrz Gdynia

    […]Every the moment in a though we pick out blogs that we read. Listed beneath are the newest web sites that we choose […]

  35. clit sex toys - September 22, 2021

    clit sex toys

    […]check below, are some completely unrelated web sites to ours, however, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  36. male sex toys - September 22, 2021

    male sex toys

    […]Here are some of the web-sites we suggest for our visitors[…]

  37. about canada pharmacy - September 21, 2021

    about canada pharmacy

    […]the time to study or take a look at the content material or web sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  38. Woking High School - September 21, 2021

    Woking High School

    […]The details mentioned within the write-up are a few of the very best accessible […]

  39. BUY MESCALINE - September 20, 2021

    BUY MESCALINE

    […]we came across a cool site which you may take pleasure in. Take a appear in case you want[…]

  40. Golden Retriever Puppies For Sale - September 20, 2021

    Golden Retriever Puppies For Sale

    […]one of our guests just lately advised the following website[…]

  41. Macaw parrots for sale - September 20, 2021

    Macaw parrots for sale

    […]we came across a cool website that you could delight in. Take a appear if you want[…]

  42. big chief carts price - September 18, 2021

    big chief carts price

    […]the time to read or take a look at the material or web sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  43. dermo care - September 17, 2021

    dermo care

  44. Thc oil cartridge - September 17, 2021

    Thc oil cartridge

    […]here are some links to websites that we link to mainly because we think they are worth visiting[…]

  45. murchison falls safari - September 16, 2021

    murchison falls safari

    […]Every the moment inside a while we select blogs that we read. Listed below would be the newest web-sites that we decide on […]

  46. russian books - September 14, 2021

    russian books

    […]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I enjoy but really don’t get lots of link adore from[…]

  47. beretta m9 for sale - September 10, 2021

    beretta m9 for sale

    […]we came across a cool web page that you just may well enjoy. Take a look if you want[…]

  48. holy cross school mira road admission - September 9, 2021

    holy cross school mira road admission

    […]check beneath, are some totally unrelated internet sites to ours, nonetheless, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  49. best in ottawa - September 9, 2021

    best in ottawa

  50. valid shop - September 8, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] There you will find 75846 more Information on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/08/penny-simkin-hypocrite.html […]

  51. 1xbit mobile - September 8, 2021

    1xbit mobile

    […]Here are several of the web-sites we suggest for our visitors[…]

  52. rechargeable bullet vibrator - September 8, 2021

    rechargeable bullet vibrator

    […]the time to read or visit the material or internet sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  53. how to use a silicone penis ring - September 7, 2021

    how to use a silicone penis ring

    […]although web sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they are truly really worth a go through, so possess a look[…]

  54. best male masturbator - September 6, 2021

    best male masturbator

  55. Trusted dex ctrlcoin.io - September 4, 2021

    Trusted dex ctrlcoin.io

    […]always a large fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but do not get lots of link like from[…]

  56. melhores smartphones - September 4, 2021

    melhores smartphones

  57. french streaming - September 4, 2021

    french streaming

    […]the time to read or check out the material or web-sites we have linked to beneath the[…]

  58. streaming gratuit - September 3, 2021

    streaming gratuit

    […]Every the moment in a whilst we select blogs that we read. Listed below would be the most up-to-date sites that we choose […]

  59. site de streaming - September 2, 2021

    site de streaming

    […]check below, are some completely unrelated web sites to ours, even so, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  60. international car shipping - September 2, 2021

    international car shipping

    […]we came across a cool site that you could possibly take pleasure in. Take a look if you want[…]

  61. fatih escort - September 1, 2021

    fatih escort

    […]Here is a great Weblog You may Find Exciting that we Encourage You[…]

  62. Dank Cartridges - August 31, 2021

    Dank Cartridges

    […]just beneath, are many completely not related web-sites to ours, however, they are surely really worth going over[…]

  63. اظهار اسم المتصل - August 30, 2021

    اظهار اسم المتصل

    […]very few sites that happen to be comprehensive below, from our point of view are undoubtedly very well worth checking out[…]

  64. realistic dildo reviews - August 30, 2021

    realistic dildo reviews

    […]please stop by the web sites we stick to, such as this a single, because it represents our picks from the web[…]

  65. male strokers - August 29, 2021

    male strokers

    […]please take a look at the web-sites we comply with, such as this a single, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  66. prostate orgasm - August 29, 2021

    prostate orgasm

    […]the time to read or check out the content or web sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  67. MILF Porn - August 26, 2021

    MILF Porn

    […]Every as soon as inside a even though we pick out blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date websites that we select […]

  68. hosting deals - August 25, 2021

    hosting deals

    […]The details talked about within the article are some of the ideal obtainable […]

  69. Masturbator - August 24, 2021

    Masturbator

    […]the time to study or check out the material or websites we have linked to beneath the[…]

  70. prostate toy - August 23, 2021

    prostate toy

    […]here are some hyperlinks to web-sites that we link to simply because we feel they may be really worth visiting[…]

  71. wireless remote panties - August 23, 2021

    wireless remote panties

    […]always a massive fan of linking to bloggers that I like but do not get a good deal of link enjoy from[…]

  72. fun88 - August 22, 2021

    fun88

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nonetheless genuinely worth taking a appear, whoa did one discover about Mid East has got additional problerms as well […]

  73. dispensary that ship to texas - August 21, 2021

    dispensary that ship to texas

  74. prostate vibrator - August 16, 2021

    prostate vibrator

    […]Here are a number of the web sites we advocate for our visitors[…]

  75. sex education - August 14, 2021

    sex education

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a couple of unrelated data, nonetheless actually worth taking a appear, whoa did a single understand about Mid East has got extra problerms as well […]

  76. bebek escort - August 13, 2021

    bebek escort

    […]always a major fan of linking to bloggers that I like but do not get quite a bit of link love from[…]

  77. AMI Hospital Management - August 13, 2021

    AMI Hospital Management

    […]the time to study or pay a visit to the subject material or websites we have linked to beneath the[…]

  78. handheld massager - August 12, 2021

    handheld massager

    […]please visit the internet sites we stick to, like this one, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  79. penis enlargement sleeve - August 4, 2021

    penis enlargement sleeve

    […]Here are a few of the sites we advise for our visitors[…]

  80. pocket pussy - August 4, 2021

    pocket pussy

    […]one of our visitors just lately recommended the following website[…]

  81. Buy Ruger Online - July 27, 2021

    Buy Ruger Online

    […]please check out the web sites we stick to, which includes this one, because it represents our picks from the web[…]

  82. mail order weed online usa - July 26, 2021

    mail order weed online usa

    […]the time to read or pay a visit to the subject material or sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  83. where to buy flavored juul pods - July 25, 2021

    where to buy flavored juul pods

    […]just beneath, are various entirely not associated sites to ours, on the other hand, they’re certainly worth going over[…]

  84. BUY HBCUC - July 25, 2021

    BUY HBCUC

    […]please check out the web sites we comply with, which includes this 1, as it represents our picks from the web[…]

  85. learn more - July 24, 2021

    learn more

    […]Every the moment inside a though we choose blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date web sites that we opt for […]

  86. sex toys - July 23, 2021

    sex toys

    […]Here is an excellent Blog You may Discover Interesting that we Encourage You[…]

  87. how to get rid of belly fat - July 18, 2021

    how to get rid of belly fat

    […]below you will locate the link to some internet sites that we consider you should visit[…]

  88. 6.5 grendel bulk ammo - July 16, 2021

    6.5 grendel bulk ammo

    […]one of our guests a short while ago proposed the following website[…]

  89. Chaise Lounge Sofa - July 14, 2021

    Chaise Lounge Sofa

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated information, nevertheless truly really worth taking a search, whoa did 1 find out about Mid East has got additional problerms at the same time […]

  90. Roofers Parksville - July 13, 2021

    Roofers Parksville

    […]Every after inside a though we select blogs that we study. Listed below are the most current websites that we decide on […]

  91. istanbul eskort bayan - July 13, 2021

    istanbul eskort bayan

    […]usually posts some really interesting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  92. Google - July 7, 2021

    Google

  93. Cyprus Wedding Photographer - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]that is the finish of this write-up. Here you’ll find some websites that we think you’ll appreciate, just click the hyperlinks over[…]…

  94. Margery Stacker - February 15, 2013

    Gems form the internet…

    […]very few websites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[…]……

  95. banos - February 15, 2013

    Looking around…

    While I was browsing today I saw a excellent post concerning…

  96. wedding planner - February 15, 2013

    Online Article……

    […]The information mentioned in the article are some of the best available […]……

  97. home insurance quote florida - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]The info talked about within the write-up are some of the most effective offered […]…

  98. primal burn system - February 15, 2013

    Recent Blogroll Additions……

    […]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[…]……

  99. hair - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]The facts talked about within the article are a number of the best obtainable […]…

  100. casinos en ligne - February 15, 2013

    Cool sites…

    […]we came across a cool site that you might enjoy. Take a look if you want[…]……

  101. Casinos en ligne - February 15, 2013

    Cool sites…

    […]we came across a cool site that you might be interested in. Take a look if you want[…]……

  102. www.HomeBusinessQuickStart.com - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]Here are a few of the sites we suggest for our visitors[…]…

  103. gold - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]usually posts some really intriguing stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.