Human rights in childbirth: does the baby have any?

I’ve noted in the past that homebirth and natural childbirth advocates love mantras and memes. They represent simple ways to communicate complex ideas, make wonderful sound bites, and for advocates, whether or not they are true is irrelevant.

I’ve written about the “obstetricians ignore the scientific evidence” mantra, which doesn’t make sense if you think about it for any length of time.

We are supposed to believe that obstetricians (with 8 years of higher education, extensive study of science and statistics, and four additional years of hands on experience caring for pregnant women), the people who actually DO the research that represents the corpus of scientific evidence, are ignoring their own findings while NCB advocates (generally high school graduates with no background in college science or statistics, let alone advanced study of these subjects, and limited experience of caring for pregnant women), the people who NEVER do scientific research, are assiduously scouring the scientific literature, reading the main obstetric journals each month, and changing their practice based on the latest scientific evidence.

I’ve also written about the meme that the media is to blame for the pain of childbirth.

… Childbirth is not inherently painful; its depictions in popular media like TV shows and movies tricks women into believing that childbirth is painful. Hence the otherwise inexplicable preoccupation on NCB blogs with how childbirth is portrayed in specific TV shows and movies.

That one isn’t getting much traction since it is obvious that it isn’t true. The people who wrote the Bible thousands of years ago were so impressed by the pain of childbirth that they explained it as God’s punishment, and they weren’t exposed to many TV shows or movies.

The latest meme in homebirth and natural childbirth circles is “human rights in childbirth.”

That’s the name of a conference organized by, for and restricted to homebirth advocates. And it figures prominently in a new film make the rounds in homebirth and natural childbirth circles, Freedom for Birth.

Freedom for Birth is a new 60 minute campaigning film that re-frames Human Rights as the most pressing issue in childbirth today.

In many countries around the world, women are being denied the most basic human right of autonomy over their own bodies. They cannot choose how and where to give birth. Those that persist in their desire to have a normal, physiological birth are sometimes forced by judges to surrender to surgery or threatened with having their babies taken away by child welfare services.

In other words, the meme of human rights in childbirth refer to the rights of the mother.

Let’s leave aside for the moment the fact that there is no legal or ethical right to have a homebirth; the right of autonomy allows for the refusal of hospital care (or any medical care), but it does not mandate an obligation on the part of others to provide a specific form of care.

Let’s ask an obvious question: does the baby have any human rights in childbirth?

The baby? You remember the baby, the other individual whose life is at stake during the process of birth? What about the baby?

I’m not talking about legal rights. Children have virtually no legal rights before birth. I’m talking about moral rights. When a mother makes the decision to take a pregnancy to term, does the baby have a moral right to receive appropriate and life-saving medical care?

Let me be very clear: I’m not talking about the rare situation in which the mother’s life is pitted against the life of the baby. The mother has the unfettered right to determine treatment in that setting. But homebirth and natural childbirth advocates are not talking about that situation, either. As the movie details make clear, homebirth and natural childbirth advocates are talking about the “desire to have a normal, physiological birth.”

So in a very real sense, the question is: Does a baby have a moral right to receive life-saving medical care when the mother is refusing it for no better reason that to have a specific birth “experience”?

Philososphy Professor Julian Savulescu and obstetrician Lach De Crespigny of the Oxford University Centre for Practical Ethics believe that a baby does have that moral right.  They make their case in an article entitled The Continuing Tragedies of Home Birth and the Rights of the Future Child.

The authors acknowledge:

… [T]he fetus has few ethical or legal rights; maternal autonomy includes the right to risk perinatal death as well as her own death. Ultimately women have autonomy regarding whether to take such risks. Professionals and pregnant women have an ethical obligation to minimise risk of long term harm to the future child; harm to people who will exist is a clear and uncontroversial morally relevant harm. Consistent with this, antenatal care focuses on minimizing the risk of harm to the future child, whether by advocating for alcohol abstinence in pregnancy, folic acid supplementation to reduce the chance of neural tube defect, or minimizing teratogenic risks of medications in pregnancy.

But:

Maternal and perinatal mortality are truly tragic outcomes. Professionals must encourage women to deliver in a safe environment and also practice safe and competent obstetrics. The professional bodies and the law must do all they can to ensure this happens.

… [T]he silent tragedies are not the deaths, but the long term disability that results from homebirth. And it is this risk that weighs most heavily against homebirth.

What disability? When a baby is obstructed in labour at home, or born with hypoxic brain injury, the delay in transferring to a tertiary hospital may result in permanent severe disability that will persist for the rest of that person’s life. In some cases, that disability was avoidable if the delivery had occurred in hospital. To take an extreme example, a person might be avoidably quadriplegic.

Now what risk could should a parent take to have “a really lovely spontaneous birth at home” that justifies quadriplegia? One in 1000? One in 1000 000? Anything?

We contend that the choice to have “a really lovely spontaneous birth at home” is only justified if exposes the future child to zero risk of avoidable disability. And this is just never the case. (my emphasis)

I would agree. Simply put, an unborn term baby has a moral right to receive potentially life-saving medical care, and that moral right is not trumped by something as trivial as the mother’s desire for a specific birth “experience.” This is analogous to a right of a child already born to receive life-saving medical care. That is a legal as well as a moral right. The parents’ desire to avoid medical care, to substitute prayer, or to simply ignore the child’s distress pales into insignificance next to the child’s legal right to life-saving care.

And as Savulescu and De Crespigny note, there is more at stake than simply the child’s right to live. The child also has a moral right to be born with the full complement of brain cells and potential that it possesses at the start of labor. The child has a moral right to receive care that minimizes the risk of brain injury and that mother’s desire for a specific birth “experience” pales into insignificance next to that moral right.

So the next time a homebirth or natural childbirth advocate insists that childbirth is a human rights issue don’t hesitate to ask the obvious question: what human rights in childbirth does the baby have?

67 Responses to “Human rights in childbirth: does the baby have any?”

  1. February 5, 2014 at 3:53 pm #

    Feminists sometimes spell it that way but it seems only hippie types use it these days. As a feminist I believe all women have the right to medical care including a safe sanitary hospital birth so it is sad to see this term appropriated by people who believe a less safe form of birth is better for ideological reasons.

  2. February 5, 2014 at 3:45 pm #

    Most places do not allow women to abort at any point during their pregnancy.

  3. February 5, 2014 at 3:44 pm #

    Many women around the world still do not have access to hospital birth and have no other option than to give birth with an unskilled birth attendant.

  4. Sara Lin Wilde
    February 1, 2014 at 2:04 pm #

    ‘Baby’ and ‘fetus’ mean different things. We don’t use ‘fetus’ to describe the unborn to dehumanize them; we do it because a fetus is morally and legally different from a baby.

    It is possible to believe that, when a pregnancy is ending with a birth, the person being born has rights they do not have as an occupant of the womb who is using the mother’s body during gestation. It is also possible, I believe, to legitimately say that a woman has the right to abort a pregnancy she does not consent to continue, but that providing consent to continue brings with it certain moral obligations to the potential person being developed.

    Thus I would say there’s a big difference between a woman who says “I do not consent to carry this pregnancy to term” and a woman who says “I’m carrying this pregnancy to term, the end result of which will involve adding a new person to the world. However, I will forego the means at my disposal to ensure that new person has its optimal health and mental faculties at birth”. That mentality treats the new person being born at the end of the pregnancy as a possession of the parents, like a handbag or a pair of shoes, when the reality is that your accessories will never have to make their own way in the world or face the consequences of having been your property.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. sex toys for couples - July 23, 2021

    sex toys for couples

    […]please check out the web sites we comply with, including this one particular, because it represents our picks through the web[…]

  2. painted sheds - July 21, 2021

    painted sheds

    […]one of our guests just lately advised the following website[…]

  3. how to get rid of belly fat - July 18, 2021

    how to get rid of belly fat

  4. bulk dungeness crab for sale - July 16, 2021

    bulk dungeness crab for sale

    […]Here are several of the websites we recommend for our visitors[…]

  5. Buy Vape Carts Online - July 14, 2021

    Buy Vape Carts Online

    https://theclearconcerntrate.com/ The Clear classic oil is mixed with CBD isolate and our preparatory flavorings for the best taste and consistency on the market today.

  6. Mexican Black Kingsnake - July 14, 2021

    Mexican Black Kingsnake

    […]please check out the web pages we stick to, which includes this one, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  7. boho coffee table - July 14, 2021

    boho coffee table

    […]The data mentioned inside the write-up are a few of the top readily available […]

  8. My Homepage - July 14, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Informations on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/09/human-rights-in-childbirth-does-the-baby-have-any.html […]

  9. canada pharmacy - July 14, 2021

    canada pharmacy

    […]check below, are some totally unrelated web sites to ours, nevertheless, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  10. Roofers - July 13, 2021

    Roofers

    […]The information mentioned inside the report are a few of the most effective offered […]

  11. escort bayan istanbul - July 13, 2021

    escort bayan istanbul

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a number of unrelated information, nevertheless genuinely worth taking a search, whoa did 1 find out about Mid East has got a lot more problerms also […]

  12. istanbul eskort bayan - July 13, 2021

    istanbul eskort bayan

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  13. MILF Porn - July 12, 2021

    MILF Porn

    […]just beneath, are quite a few completely not related web sites to ours, nevertheless, they are certainly worth going over[…]

  14. MURANG'A UNIVERSITY - July 9, 2021

    MURANG’A UNIVERSITY

  15. Takeout Parksville - July 8, 2021

    Takeout Parksville

  16. Glock Guns for sale - July 8, 2021

    Glock Guns for sale

    […]very couple of websites that take place to be comprehensive below, from our point of view are undoubtedly properly really worth checking out[…]

  17. Investor obligasi - July 8, 2021

    Investor obligasi

    […]below you will obtain the link to some web-sites that we assume you’ll want to visit[…]

  18. moving company Kelowna - July 7, 2021

    moving company Kelowna

    […]one of our visitors not long ago encouraged the following website[…]

  19. hemp carts for sale - July 6, 2021

    hemp carts for sale

  20. ptr 9ct for sale - July 6, 2021

    ptr 9ct for sale

    […]Here are a few of the websites we recommend for our visitors[…]

  21. buy ruger guns online - July 6, 2021

    buy ruger guns online

    […]just beneath, are many absolutely not connected web pages to ours, even so, they may be surely worth going over[…]

  22. albino a+ - July 6, 2021

    albino a+

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated data, nevertheless actually worth taking a search, whoa did one study about Mid East has got extra problerms at the same time […]

  23. tiktok followers - July 5, 2021

    tiktok followers

    […]although web sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we really feel they’re essentially really worth a go by way of, so have a look[…]

  24. SF Examiner - July 5, 2021

    SF Examiner

  25. how to buy weed online - July 5, 2021

    how to buy weed online

    […]very few web sites that come about to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out[…]

  26. Seattle Weekly - July 5, 2021

    Seattle Weekly

  27. buy weed - July 5, 2021

    buy weed

  28. Herald Net - July 5, 2021

    Herald Net

    […]check below, are some completely unrelated internet websites to ours, however, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  29. BUY SHARKLATO EXOTICS - July 4, 2021

    BUY SHARKLATO EXOTICS

    […]here are some hyperlinks to internet sites that we link to simply because we consider they may be really worth visiting[…]

  30. waterproof vibrator - July 3, 2021

    waterproof vibrator

    […]one of our visitors not long ago recommended the following website[…]

  31. female vibrator - July 3, 2021

    female vibrator

  32. bachelor's degree - July 1, 2021

    bachelor’s degree

    […]the time to study or stop by the material or web sites we have linked to beneath the[…]

  33. weed near me - June 29, 2021

    weed near me

    […]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but really don’t get a whole lot of link really like from[…]

  34. where to buy delta 8 - June 29, 2021

    where to buy delta 8

    […]Here is an excellent Weblog You may Come across Exciting that we Encourage You[…]

  35. Best THC Gummies - June 29, 2021

    Best THC Gummies

    […]Here is an excellent Blog You might Discover Exciting that we Encourage You[…]

  36. strapon dildo - June 27, 2021

    strapon dildo

    […]Every once in a although we select blogs that we read. Listed beneath are the latest internet sites that we decide on […]

  37. Food License - June 26, 2021

    Food License

    […]although web sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we really feel they may be basically worth a go via, so possess a look[…]

  38. tides today at tides.today - June 24, 2021

    tides today at tides.today

  39. adam and eve discount codes - June 22, 2021

    adam and eve discount codes

    […]please go to the web-sites we stick to, which includes this a single, because it represents our picks from the web[…]

  40. best delta 8 thc gummies - June 22, 2021

    best delta 8 thc gummies

  41. Mobile Phone repair mission Viejo - June 22, 2021

    Mobile Phone repair mission Viejo

  42. best delta 8 THC vape cartridges - June 21, 2021

    best delta 8 THC vape cartridges

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated data, nonetheless definitely really worth taking a search, whoa did 1 master about Mid East has got far more problerms as well […]

  43. buy Instagram likes - June 21, 2021

    buy Instagram likes

    […]usually posts some incredibly fascinating stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  44. best delta 8 - June 21, 2021

    best delta 8

    […]Every the moment inside a although we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the newest websites that we select […]

  45. buy real Instagram likes - June 21, 2021

    buy real Instagram likes

  46. best kratom - June 21, 2021

    best kratom

    […]always a large fan of linking to bloggers that I enjoy but do not get a whole lot of link like from[…]

  47. where to buy kratom - June 21, 2021

    where to buy kratom

    […]please check out the web sites we stick to, including this 1, because it represents our picks through the web[…]

  48. kratom capsules - June 21, 2021

    kratom capsules

    […]here are some hyperlinks to web pages that we link to mainly because we consider they are worth visiting[…]

  49. MASALA MACHINE - June 17, 2021

    MASALA MACHINE

    […]below you will locate the link to some internet sites that we believe it is best to visit[…]

  50. latest technology. news - June 16, 2021

    latest technology. news

    […]please pay a visit to the web-sites we follow, which includes this one particular, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  51. Longliqicn Login - June 16, 2021

    Longliqicn Login

    […]although sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they’re in fact worth a go by way of, so possess a look[…]

  52. PARROTS FOR SALE - June 16, 2021

    PARROTS FOR SALE

    […]The information and facts mentioned inside the post are a number of the most beneficial available […]

  53. Guns for Sale Near Me - June 16, 2021

    Guns for Sale Near Me

    […]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[…]

  54. GOLDEN RETRIEVER PUPPIES FOR SALE - June 16, 2021

    GOLDEN RETRIEVER PUPPIES FOR SALE

    […]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[…]

  55. Buy Weed Online - June 15, 2021

    Buy Weed Online

    […]here are some hyperlinks to sites that we link to mainly because we assume they’re really worth visiting[…]

  56. batman pinball machine - June 15, 2021

    batman pinball machine

    […]below you will come across the link to some websites that we feel you should visit[…]

  57. fresh alligator meat for sale - June 15, 2021

    fresh alligator meat for sale

    […]Every after inside a even though we decide on blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the most recent web-sites that we select […]

  58. g spot vibrators - June 15, 2021

    g spot vibrators

    […]here are some links to sites that we link to due to the fact we think they may be worth visiting[…]

  59. Google - June 14, 2021

    Google

    Here is a superb Blog You might Uncover Fascinating that we encourage you to visit.

  60. Google - June 2, 2021

    Google

    Always a significant fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but do not get a lot of link really like from.

  61. lessons - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]check beneath, are some absolutely unrelated internet websites to ours, however, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]…

  62. http://www.routingcheck.com/bank-of-new-york-routing-number.html - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]always a major fan of linking to bloggers that I like but really don’t get a whole lot of link love from[…]…

  63. homeowners insurance quotes in florida - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]Here is an excellent Blog You may Discover Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.