Is electronic fetal monitoring a failure?

The latest edition of the journal Obstetrics and Gynecology contains a commentary destined to make a splash: Electronic Fetal Monitoring as a Public Health Screening Program; The Arithmetic of Failure by Drs. David Grimes and Jeffrey Piepert. The article makes a bold claim:

Electronic fetal monitoring has failed as a public health screening program… Because of low-prevalence target conditions and mediocre validity, the positive predictive value of electronic fetal monitoring for fetal death in labor or cerebral palsy is near zero. Stated alternatively, almost every positive test result is wrong…

It is critical to note that the authors are not claiming that fetal monitoring is a failure, merely that electronic fetal monitoring fails to provide additional benefits over monitoring by intermittently listening to the fetal heart rate. The authors provide a breathless analysis of the causes for this purported failure, implying that basic statistical analysis made this failure easily predictable.

In my judgment, the authors commit two serious, and inexplicable, errors.

1. Although, the authors provide a detailed statistical analysis of the limited ability of electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) to detect fetal death (stillbirth), such an analysis utterly misses the point. The purpose of electronic fetal monitoring is not to detect fetal death, but to prevent it. The primary purpose of fetal monitoring (whether by auscultation or electronic) is to diagnose fetal distress in progress, not to diagnose death, the end point of severe fetal distress. Curiously, the authors give short shrift to this. And since the authors virtually ignore the primary purpose of the test, their analysis, while sure to garner headlines, is not particularly compelling.

2. The authors complain that screening for rare events leads to tests with poor predictive value. Fortunately, adverse outcomes in labor are relatively rare. That’s why neonatal deaths are expressed per 1,000 births. Therefore, it is not a surprise that screening for poor fetal outcomes has a poor predictive value. But if are goal is to prevent rare events, that is virtually inevitable.

The authors explain the nature of screening tests and the measurements that determine the validity of a screening test, including positive predictive value, negative predictive value and the impact of prevalence. I performed a similar analysis in a post written 2 years ago (Sensitivity, specificity and fetal monitoring). I used round numbers to illustrate the concept and it may helpful to read my post before reading the actual paper.

The key finding of the Grimes, Piepert paper is this:

Here, electronic fetal monitoring is assumed to have a sensitivity of 57% and specificity of 69%,7 and the prevalence of fetal death is low: 50 per 100,000… [T]he predictive value of a positive electronic fetal monitoring screen [is] 29/31,013, which rounds off to zero percent. Because of poor test specificity, more than 30,000 false-positive tests … overwhelm fewer than 30 true-positive results … Given a worrisome tracing, the probability of fetal death is, rounded to percent, nil.

In other words, if EFM is used to predict which babies will definitely die, only 1/1000 will actually die. That seems compelling until you consider that EFM is not used to identify babies who will definitely die, it is used to identify babies who are not getting enough oxygen and therefore may suffer permanent brain damage or die. As the authors briefly acknowledge in what is virtually an aside, EFM performs very differently in that situation.

More common but less serious, fetal acidemia at birth [as a result of low oxygen in labor] may provide the most charitable assessment of electronic fetal monitoring. In a large randomized controlled trial with a frequency of fetal acidemia at birth (umbilical cord artery pH less than 7.15) of 10%, nonreassuring fetal heart rate patterns had a positive predictive value of 37%.13 Even for this common outcome, most positive tests were wrong.

Yes, the majority of babies identified as suffering from oxygen deprivation turn out to be fine, but 37 out of 100 (more than 1/3) are suffering from oxygen deprivation so severe that it may result in brain damage or death. That’s a number too large to ignore.

For perspective, it helps to consider a real world example, like mammography. The positive predictive value of mammograms is low. Most abnormal findings on mammography turn out to be benign. The positive predictive value for screening mammography in detecting breast cancer is in the range of 10%, considerably less that the PPV for electronic fetal monitoring in detecting oxygen deprivation (37%).

Moreover, routine mammographic screening of women under 50 saves only 1 life per 1400 women screened. That’s a PPV for preventing death of 0.07%, nearly zero using the methodology that Grimes and Piepert applied to EFM. Nonetheless, the recent recommendation to suspend routine screening of women under 50 met with a firestorm of protest.

The bottom line is that obstetricians are well aware of the serious limitations of electronic fetal monitoring. For every neonatal life saved, for every case of brain damage averted, hundreds if not thousands of monitoring strips falsely predict fetal oxygen deprivation. The issue is not whether fetal monitoring is a good screening test; everyone knows that it is a bad screening test. The problem is that there is no screening test that’s better.

The question we face is not whether EFM is highly effective, the question is whether EFM is worth it. That’s an ethical issue, not an arithmetic one.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. knalls - July 24, 2021

    knalls

    […]check below, are some absolutely unrelated web sites to ours, even so, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  2. سكس - July 24, 2021

    سكس

    […]please go to the websites we follow, such as this one, because it represents our picks through the web[…]

  3. top sex toys for women - July 23, 2021

    top sex toys for women

    […]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we feel they may be essentially worth a go by way of, so have a look[…]

  4. insulated shed - July 21, 2021

    insulated shed

    […]always a significant fan of linking to bloggers that I like but do not get quite a bit of link love from[…]

  5. bunnings shed - July 21, 2021

    bunnings shed

    […]very handful of internet websites that transpire to become in depth below, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out[…]

  6. how to lose belly fat - July 18, 2021

    how to lose belly fat

    […]one of our guests just lately suggested the following website[…]

  7. whole alligator meat for sale - July 16, 2021

    whole alligator meat for sale

    […]very handful of web-sites that happen to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly very well really worth checking out[…]

  8. Elliptical - July 16, 2021

    Elliptical

    […]although sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we feel they may be truly really worth a go by means of, so possess a look[…]

  9. ar 15 drum magazine 5.56 nato 223 rem 100 rounds - July 16, 2021

    ar 15 drum magazine 5.56 nato 223 rem 100 rounds

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  10. mexican redknee tarantula for sale - July 14, 2021

    mexican redknee tarantula for sale

    […]usually posts some very fascinating stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  11. Thc Oil Carts - July 14, 2021

    Thc Oil Carts

    https://theclearconcerntrate.com/ The Clear classic oil is mixed with CBD isolate and our preparatory flavorings for the best taste and consistency on the market today.

  12. captain beds near me - July 14, 2021

    captain beds near me

  13. sig romeo5 for sale - July 14, 2021

    sig romeo5 for sale

    […]that is the finish of this article. Right here you will uncover some sites that we believe you will value, just click the hyperlinks over[…]

  14. online pharmacies canada - July 13, 2021

    online pharmacies canada

    […]check below, are some absolutely unrelated internet websites to ours, however, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  15. canadapharmacy.com - July 13, 2021

    canadapharmacy.com

    […]check below, are some entirely unrelated web sites to ours, however, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  16. Roofing Services - July 13, 2021

    Roofing Services

    […]that may be the finish of this report. Right here you will locate some sites that we think you will value, just click the links over[…]

  17. umraniye escort - July 13, 2021

    umraniye escort

    […]although web-sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we really feel they’re truly worth a go as a result of, so possess a look[…]

  18. istanbul escort - July 13, 2021

    istanbul escort

    […]please stop by the internet sites we stick to, like this a single, because it represents our picks in the web[…]

  19. MILF Porn Land - July 12, 2021

    MILF Porn Land

    […]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but really don’t get lots of link really like from[…]

  20. MURANG'A UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY - July 9, 2021

    MURANG’A UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY

    […]just beneath, are numerous entirely not associated web sites to ours, however, they may be surely really worth going over[…]

  21. Restaurants Parksville - July 8, 2021

    Restaurants Parksville

    […]one of our visitors not long ago advised the following website[…]

  22. Takeout Food - July 8, 2021

    Takeout Food

  23. Obligasi.com - July 8, 2021

    Obligasi.com

  24. moving company - July 7, 2021

    moving company

    […]one of our guests lately suggested the following website[…]

  25. Kelowna moving company - July 7, 2021

    Kelowna moving company

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  26. Ruger Handguns - July 6, 2021

    Ruger Handguns

    […]very handful of web sites that happen to become in depth below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[…]

  27. vape carts for sale uk - July 6, 2021

    vape carts for sale uk

    […]check below, are some completely unrelated internet websites to ours, nevertheless, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  28. abc rifle company - July 6, 2021

    abc rifle company

    […]please stop by the web-sites we comply with, like this a single, as it represents our picks from the web[…]

  29. Ruger Revolvers - July 6, 2021

    Ruger Revolvers

    […]the time to read or go to the subject material or web-sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  30. Ruger Rifles - July 6, 2021

    Ruger Rifles

    […]the time to read or visit the subject material or web sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  31. how long do shrooms stay in your system - July 6, 2021

    how long do shrooms stay in your system

    […]below you will uncover the link to some internet sites that we think it is best to visit[…]

  32. tiktok followers - July 5, 2021

    tiktok followers

    […]Here is a good Weblog You may Find Exciting that we Encourage You[…]

  33. shroom supply - July 5, 2021

    shroom supply

  34. buy weed - July 5, 2021

    buy weed

    […]please take a look at the web pages we follow, such as this 1, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  35. SF Examiner - July 5, 2021

    SF Examiner

    […]very few sites that occur to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[…]

  36. marijuana dispensaries - July 5, 2021

    marijuana dispensaries

    […]The info mentioned inside the write-up are a few of the most effective out there […]

  37. buy weed - July 5, 2021

    buy weed

    […]please visit the sites we adhere to, such as this 1, because it represents our picks through the web[…]

  38. Herald Net - July 5, 2021

    Herald Net

    […]here are some hyperlinks to web sites that we link to because we consider they are worth visiting[…]

  39. BUY THC JUICE VAPE - July 4, 2021

    BUY THC JUICE VAPE

    […]one of our visitors a short while ago proposed the following website[…]

  40. classic vibrator - July 3, 2021

    classic vibrator

    […]Here is a superb Weblog You might Discover Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  41. weird sex toy - July 3, 2021

    weird sex toy

    […]check beneath, are some totally unrelated internet sites to ours, nonetheless, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  42. Sunucu Teknik Destek - July 3, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Info to that Topic: skepticalob.com/2010/12/is-electronic-fetal-monitoring-failure.html […]

  43. Google - July 2, 2021

    Google

    Below you will discover the link to some sites that we assume it is best to visit.

  44. bachelor's degree - July 1, 2021

    bachelor’s degree

    […]just beneath, are numerous entirely not related web sites to ours, having said that, they’re surely worth going over[…]

  45. best cbd gummies - June 29, 2021

    best cbd gummies

    […]please take a look at the web-sites we adhere to, such as this a single, because it represents our picks in the web[…]

  46. best THC gummies - June 29, 2021

    best THC gummies

    […]Every when in a although we select blogs that we study. Listed beneath are the latest websites that we select […]

  47. strap on vibrator - June 27, 2021

    strap on vibrator

    […]that may be the end of this article. Here you will locate some web pages that we assume you will enjoy, just click the links over[…]

  48. best delta 8 THC vape cartridges - June 22, 2021

    best delta 8 THC vape cartridges

    […]here are some links to web sites that we link to due to the fact we feel they may be worth visiting[…]

  49. best delta 8 - June 21, 2021

    best delta 8

    […]the time to read or take a look at the content material or sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  50. buy real Instagram likes - June 21, 2021

    buy real Instagram likes

    […]the time to read or take a look at the content material or web-sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  51. where to buy kratom - June 21, 2021

    where to buy kratom

    […]just beneath, are many absolutely not connected web-sites to ours, nonetheless, they may be certainly worth going over[…]

  52. Pound of Weed - June 16, 2021

    Pound of Weed

    […]Every the moment inside a although we pick blogs that we study. Listed below would be the most current internet sites that we pick out […]

  53. GOLDEN RETRIEVER PUPPIES FOR SALE - June 16, 2021

    GOLDEN RETRIEVER PUPPIES FOR SALE

    […]usually posts some very intriguing stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  54. bulk pork belly - June 16, 2021

    bulk pork belly

    […]although websites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we really feel they’re basically worth a go by way of, so possess a look[…]

  55. how to enjoy g spot sex toys - June 15, 2021

    how to enjoy g spot sex toys

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a number of unrelated data, nonetheless actually really worth taking a search, whoa did one understand about Mid East has got far more problerms too […]

  56. Google - June 13, 2021

    Google

    Just beneath, are quite a few totally not related web pages to ours, having said that, they are certainly worth going over.

  57. Text your ex back - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]one of our guests a short while ago recommended the following website[…]…

  58. gaming forums - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]Here is a great Weblog You may Locate Interesting that we Encourage You[…]…

  59. http://www.routingcheck.com/us-bank-routing-number.html - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]below you’ll come across the link to some websites that we consider it is best to visit[…]…

  60. study - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]the time to study or take a look at the subject material or web pages we have linked to beneath the[…]…

  61. silver - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]just beneath, are several entirely not associated internet sites to ours, on the other hand, they’re surely worth going over[…]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.