Melissa Cheyney is not the only anthropologist of birth

Yesterday I wrote about Melissa Cheyney’s disquisition on the anthropology of birth. Cheyney does provide insight into the “meaning making” of natural childbirth and homebirth advocates, but she does so from a position of complete credulousness. Since she (herself a homebirth midwife as well as an anthropologist) is part of the subculture she is investigating, she does not question the meanings, the meaning-making or the relationship of such meaning-making to reality. It as if an anthropologist writing on human sacrifice ascribed to the belief that the gods could be propitiated by throwing virgin girls into volcanoes, and having accepted that assumption, proceeded to describe the meaning and meaning-making of the ceremonies surrounding the sacrifices.

Cheyney, however, is not the only anthropologist of birth. There are others whose work is not colored by the need to justify the beliefs of the natural childbirth/homebirth subcultures. Consider the chapter The Dialectics of Disruption: Paradoxes of Nature and Professionalism in Contemporary American Childbearing by Caroline Bledsoe and Rachel Scherrer. It appears in the book Reproductive Disruptions: Gender, Technology, and Biopolitics in the New Millennium.

The chapter covers many areas of the anthropology of childbirth in contemporary first world countries. The one that is relevant for our current discussion is the issue of meaning-making explained by Cheyney. However, they go far beyond Cheyney in that they explore why and how NCB/homebirth advocates have come to believe what they do. Unlike Cheyney, who so eagerly accepts the meanings and meaning-making of contemporary NCB/homebirth advocates, Bledsoe and Scherrer examine why meaning-making is so important within the subculture.

Their description of the current situation is spot on:

Birthing is depicted culturally as an individual achievement, one in which a woman should be in control of her actions. For this, women attempt to present themselves as professionals, medical as well as legal: as close as they can come to being equals with their medical peer doctors, informed and trained to evaluate their qualifications (my emphasis).

Bledsoe and Scherrer recognize that meanings and meaning-making are luxuries of a society in which childbirth is so safe that women have forgotten that in reality it is inherently dangerous:

… As childbearing became safer and more benign visions of nature arose, undesired outcomes of birth for women came to consist of a bad experience and psychological damage from missed bonding opportunities. Today, with safety taken for granted, the new goal has become in some sense the process itself: the experience of childbirth… (my emphasis)

In other words, as I have written repeatedly since for NCB/homebirth advocates outcome is taken for granted, the focus has shifted entirely to process. And the most critical element in the process, the one to which the most significance is imputed, is control.

Their critical insight:

… But with *control* being such a crucial issue in cultural ideals of childbearing, the greater the expectations that a scripted birth plan creates, the greater the surety that the woman will fall short of her ideal. Some elements will go wrong, and with them the hope of remaining the equal of the professionals who deals with her birth. This relegates obstetricians, who have the power to disrupt a naturalism but also to save lives if something goes wrong, to being the inevitable targets of opposition. (my emphasis)

Specifically:

If nature is defined as whatever obstetricians do not do, then the degree to which a birth can be called natural is inversely proportional to the degree to which an obstetrician appears to play a role. The answer to why obstetricians are described with such antipathy thus lies not in the substance of what obstetricians do that is unnatural – whether the use of sharp incision. forceps, and medications that blunt sensation. or anything else- but in the fact that obstetricians represent a woman’s loss of control over the birth event. Obstetricians are thus perceived as the chief source of disruption in the birth event, backed by the licensing power of medicine and the law. And yet it is not what obstetricians do that women find problematic but the fact that they are the people who step in when the woman is seen to have failed. (my emphasis)

In other words, as I have written repeatedly, the “natural” in natural childbirth has nothing to do with nature. Natural is defined as anything a midwife can do. In contrast, if only an obstetrician knows how to do it, it is “unnatural” by definition in the NCB subculture.

The authors summarize:

… Today, because of medical and technological advances that have brought so many of the life-threatening complications of childbirth under control, the naturalism in childbirth that women now envision is not only benign but desirable. But to the extent that childbearing remains less about nature than control, animosity will likely continue to be directed at doctors because they represent failure to attain nature, and animosity will continue to be directed at obstetricians, regardless of what they actually do or what their gender is. (my emphasis)

Ultimately, there is nothing wrong with Cheyney’s attempt to describe the meanings and meaning-making of contemporary NCB/homebirth advocates. The problem is that she fails to question the fundamental assumptions that undergird these meanings. Just as human sacrifice only makes sense to those who believe that the gods are pleased by throwing virgins into volcanoes, natural childbirth only makes sense to those who believe that childbirth is inherently safe. And while we have no idea whether there are “gods” and whether they are pleased by human sacrifice, we do know that childbirth is not inherently safe.

Bledsoe and Scherrer understand:

… As we turn to the disruptions that preoccupy US middle-class women as they contemplate the birth of a child. it is vital to keep in mind both the dangers that reproduction can entail and the science that has allowed us to imagine as common sense a safe, uninterrupted, reproductive life trajectory.

It is precisely these points, the inherent dangers of childbirth, and the science that has allowed us to treat and prevent them, that Cheyney fails to take into account. Therefore, her analysis is flawed to the point that it is nearly nonsensical.

80 Responses to “Melissa Cheyney is not the only anthropologist of birth”

  1. Lynnsey Sorrentino
    June 29, 2014 at 1:07 pm #

    I find it very strange that this MD has chosen to compare home and natural birth advocates to people who believe in the benefits of human sacrifice. She really hasn’t done her research. My OB attended my home birth! She admits that many of her routine practices were unnecessary and she has totally revamped her practice over the years to take an approach more aligned with that of the midwife than the OB. Why? Because it made a hell of a lot more sense. Educate yourself, Dr. Instead of making fallacious arguments and comparisons based on an erroneous and relatively vacuous interpretation of the ‘other side’.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. titan blues city olympic barbell - October 23, 2021

    titan blues city olympic barbell

  2. Google - October 23, 2021

    Google

    Every the moment inside a although we pick out blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the most current web-sites that we pick.

  3. Murchison Falls Waterfall - October 22, 2021

    Murchison Falls Waterfall

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you simply may get pleasure from. Take a appear when you want[…]

  4. Bitmain Antminer S19 (95Th) Bitcoin miner - October 21, 2021

    Bitmain Antminer S19 (95Th) Bitcoin miner

    […]although internet websites we backlink to beneath are considerably not related to ours, we feel they are really worth a go by, so have a look[…]

  5. discreet weed shop in Miami - October 21, 2021

    discreet weed shop in Miami

    […]the time to study or pay a visit to the material or web pages we have linked to beneath the[…]

  6. Macaw for sale - October 20, 2021

    Macaw for sale

    […]here are some links to sites that we link to for the reason that we think they are really worth visiting[…]

  7. smith and wesson r8 - October 20, 2021

    smith and wesson r8

    […]that is the finish of this report. Here you will discover some web pages that we consider you will enjoy, just click the hyperlinks over[…]

  8. smart carts - October 18, 2021

    smart carts

    […]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[…]

  9. background check website - October 17, 2021

    background check website

  10. strawberry shortcake oil cartridge - October 17, 2021

    strawberry shortcake oil cartridge

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated data, nonetheless truly really worth taking a look, whoa did one discover about Mid East has got a lot more problerms too […]

  11. magic mushrooms - October 15, 2021

    magic mushrooms

    […]please visit the web sites we follow, like this 1, because it represents our picks in the web[…]

  12. magic mushrooms - October 15, 2021

    magic mushrooms

    […]Every once inside a whilst we select blogs that we read. Listed below would be the latest internet sites that we opt for […]

  13. Stiiizy Vape Carts - October 14, 2021

    Stiiizy Vape Carts

    […]The info talked about inside the post are a number of the best obtainable […]

  14. sig sauer p238 academy - October 14, 2021

    sig sauer p238 academy

    […]Every after inside a even though we opt for blogs that we read. Listed below would be the most recent internet sites that we pick out […]

  15. sig p320x carry - October 13, 2021

    sig p320x carry

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated information, nonetheless definitely worth taking a look, whoa did 1 discover about Mid East has got far more problerms at the same time […]

  16. benelli nova 18 inch barrel - October 13, 2021

    benelli nova 18 inch barrel

    […]Here are a few of the web-sites we recommend for our visitors[…]

  17. savage 110 tactical - October 13, 2021

    savage 110 tactical

    […]very handful of web-sites that happen to be detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely worth checking out[…]

  18. VANILLA BEAN STRAIN - October 11, 2021

    VANILLA BEAN STRAIN

    […]although websites we backlink to beneath are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they may be essentially worth a go by, so possess a look[…]

  19. Buy Viagra gold online - October 10, 2021

    Buy Viagra gold online

    […]Every when inside a although we pick out blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date internet sites that we select […]

  20. myloweslife login - October 7, 2021

    myloweslife login

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a couple of unrelated information, nonetheless really worth taking a search, whoa did 1 understand about Mid East has got extra problerms also […]

  21. izrada web sajtova - October 7, 2021

    izrada web sajtova

    Development of websites, mobile applications, portals and online stores

  22. aromatherapy for sleep - October 3, 2021

    aromatherapy for sleep

    […]here are some hyperlinks to web-sites that we link to due to the fact we believe they may be worth visiting[…]

  23. ارقام بنات - October 3, 2021

    ارقام بنات

    […]one of our guests a short while ago proposed the following website[…]

  24. Serengeti safari tour - October 3, 2021

    Serengeti safari tour

  25. shipping containers for sale - October 2, 2021

    shipping containers for sale

    […]Here is an excellent Blog You may Discover Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  26. FARMING EQUIPMENT FOR SALE IN GAUTENG - October 2, 2021

    FARMING EQUIPMENT FOR SALE IN GAUTENG

    […]check beneath, are some totally unrelated websites to ours, even so, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  27. best male sex toys - October 2, 2021

    best male sex toys

    […]please stop by the web-sites we adhere to, like this one, as it represents our picks in the web[…]

  28. Bes of Uganda gorilla wildlife safari - October 1, 2021

    Bes of Uganda gorilla wildlife safari

    […]that may be the end of this write-up. Here you will uncover some internet sites that we assume you will enjoy, just click the hyperlinks over[…]

  29. Mac akku reparieren jona - October 1, 2021

    Mac akku reparieren jona

    […]Here is a good Blog You might Locate Interesting that we Encourage You[…]

  30. Shipping containers For Sale - September 30, 2021

    Shipping containers For Sale

    […]one of our visitors not long ago proposed the following website[…]

  31. Buy Sig Sauer Firearms Online - September 27, 2021

    Buy Sig Sauer Firearms Online

    […]please visit the websites we stick to, such as this a single, as it represents our picks through the web[…]

  32. Computer Repair Bristol - September 27, 2021

    Computer Repair Bristol

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a number of unrelated data, nonetheless definitely worth taking a search, whoa did one particular master about Mid East has got much more problerms as well […]

  33. Agence de communication parisienne - September 26, 2021

    Agence de communication parisienne

    […]Every after inside a whilst we pick blogs that we read. Listed beneath are the most current internet sites that we pick […]

  34. baby sugar gliders for sale - September 26, 2021

    baby sugar gliders for sale

    […]The facts talked about in the article are several of the top obtainable […]

  35. download apps apk for laptop pc - September 24, 2021

    download apps apk for laptop pc

  36. free download for windows 8 - September 24, 2021

    free download for windows 8

    […]Here is a good Blog You might Obtain Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  37. pc games for windows 8 - September 24, 2021

    pc games for windows 8

    […]always a large fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but do not get quite a bit of link appreciate from[…]

  38. app for pc - September 24, 2021

    app for pc

    […]although sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not associated to ours, we really feel they are essentially worth a go as a result of, so have a look[…]

  39. pc apps for windows 8 - September 23, 2021

    pc apps for windows 8

    […]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I love but do not get a whole lot of link really like from[…]

  40. app for pc download - September 23, 2021

    app for pc download

    […]just beneath, are many completely not associated internet sites to ours, nonetheless, they’re surely worth going over[…]

  41. projektownie wnętrz Gdynia - September 22, 2021

    projektownie wnętrz Gdynia

    […]Here are several of the internet sites we suggest for our visitors[…]

  42. بديل تروكولر - September 22, 2021

    بديل تروكولر

    […]just beneath, are many entirely not connected web-sites to ours, nevertheless, they may be certainly worth going over[…]

  43. best sex toys for men - September 22, 2021

    best sex toys for men

    […]the time to read or take a look at the material or internet sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  44. clit sex toys - September 22, 2021

    clit sex toys

    […]the time to read or pay a visit to the content or web pages we have linked to below the[…]

  45. canadian services - September 22, 2021

    canadian services

    […]Every after in a though we pick blogs that we read. Listed below would be the most current web pages that we opt for […]

  46. Ravensbury Community School - September 21, 2021

    Ravensbury Community School

    […]we came across a cool web site that you just may possibly get pleasure from. Take a appear for those who want[…]

  47. MESCALINE FOR SALE - September 20, 2021

    MESCALINE FOR SALE

    […]Here are some of the websites we advocate for our visitors[…]

  48. dachshund puppy for sale - September 20, 2021

    dachshund puppy for sale

    […]Every once inside a while we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date internet sites that we choose […]

  49. big chief blackwater og - September 18, 2021

    big chief blackwater og

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated information, nevertheless definitely really worth taking a search, whoa did one particular learn about Mid East has got extra problerms as well […]

  50. color reus - September 17, 2021

    color reus

  51. trip to murchison falls - September 16, 2021

    trip to murchison falls

    […]usually posts some pretty exciting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]

  52. talisman lucky charms - September 14, 2021

    talisman lucky charms

    […]Every when inside a although we pick out blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the newest web sites that we choose […]

  53. stoeger m3000 for sale - September 10, 2021

    stoeger m3000 for sale

    […]just beneath, are a lot of totally not connected internet sites to ours, even so, they may be certainly worth going over[…]

  54. 안전사이트 - September 10, 2021

    안전사이트

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  55. shanti international school noida - September 9, 2021

    shanti international school noida

    […]below you will uncover the link to some web-sites that we think you should visit[…]

  56. 1xbit esports - September 8, 2021

    1xbit esports

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  57. pocket stroker - September 8, 2021

    pocket stroker

    […]check beneath, are some absolutely unrelated websites to ours, nevertheless, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  58. sex toy review - September 8, 2021

    sex toy review

    […]we came across a cool site which you may possibly appreciate. Take a search should you want[…]

  59. rechargeable penis ring - September 7, 2021

    rechargeable penis ring

  60. facts about sex - September 7, 2021

    facts about sex

  61. male masturbators - September 6, 2021

    male masturbators

  62. twitter video downloader - September 4, 2021

    twitter video downloader

    […]just beneath, are several absolutely not related web-sites to ours, having said that, they may be certainly really worth going over[…]

  63. jogar online - September 4, 2021

    jogar online

    […]the time to read or check out the subject material or internet sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  64. french streaming - September 3, 2021

    french streaming

    […]the time to read or check out the content or internet sites we’ve linked to beneath the[…]

  65. site de streaming - September 2, 2021

    site de streaming

    […]the time to study or take a look at the material or web-sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  66. Decentralized P2P Network For Secured Loans - September 1, 2021

    Decentralized P2P Network For Secured Loans

  67. Diablo strain - August 31, 2021

    Diablo strain

    […]although web sites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we feel they’re essentially worth a go by way of, so have a look[…]

  68. adam and eve dildo - August 30, 2021

    adam and eve dildo

    […]The information talked about in the article are some of the ideal readily available […]

  69. male stroker toy - August 29, 2021

    male stroker toy

  70. prostate stimulation - August 29, 2021

    prostate stimulation

  71. MILF Porn - August 28, 2021

    MILF Porn

  72. Google - August 27, 2021

    Google

  73. scooter rental in honolulu - August 12, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2011/12/melissa-cheyney-is-not-only.html […]

  74. ถาดกระดาษ - July 22, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2011/12/melissa-cheyney-is-not-only.html […]

  75. yepi games - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]Here are some of the web-sites we advocate for our visitors[…]…

  76. twitter - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]Here is a great Blog You might Uncover Interesting that we Encourage You[…]…

  77. http://sportnaslava.com/wiki/index.php?title=WashBradford589 - February 16, 2013

    Title…

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated information, nonetheless truly worth taking a look, whoa did a single learn about Mid East has got much more problerms as well […]…

  78. carpet cleaning - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]although websites we backlink to beneath are considerably not associated to ours, we feel they are really worth a go as a result of, so have a look[…]…

  79. Business Opportunity - February 15, 2013

    Title…

    […]always a major fan of linking to bloggers that I like but don’t get a great deal of link like from[…]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.