Why do lactivists think it is okay to let babies scream for hours from hunger?

Last week we heard from a cardiologist who related her experience of being made to suffer in an effort to promote breastfeeding. But how about babies? Aren’t they suffering, too?

It’s ironic when you think about it. Many of the same people who refuse infant eye ointment because the baby might be distressed by blurry vision, who refuse neonatal vitamin K because the injection will hurt the baby for a brief moment, think nothing of letting a baby (yours or theirs) scream for hours in hunger in the face of inadequate breast milk supply.

The promotion of breastfeeding invariably involves discussion of the benefits to babies of breastmilk but no one seems to care about the babies who suffer in an attempt to force them to breastfeed even when the breastfeeding relationship is not working.

Hunger is probably the most elemental of infant drives and, as anyone who has seen an infant scream from hunger would probably agree, is experienced by the baby as suffering. For most mothers, myself included, the sound of their own infant crying is piercing in its intensity and distress. I remember being surprised by this when my first child was born. I had spent my entire professional life surrounded by crying babies and it had never bothered me, yet I found my son’s crying unbearable and always rushed to determine what was wrong and fix it in any way possible. I cannot imagine letting any of my infants cry in hunger for any length of time without feeding them. Indeed I recoil when I read about the infant care manuals of the early 20th Century that advised mothers to feed the baby on a schedule designed for maternal convenience instead of infant needs.

So why do lactivists think it okay to let babies scream for hours at a time because of desperate, all consuming hunger? Why do they advise women whose babies aren’t getting enough milk in the first few days to ignore that crying in an effort to promote breastfeeding? Why do they view supplementation in the first view days as an evil so great that it is preferable to force babies to endure distress?

Why do lactivists think it is okay to ignore an infant who is not gaining weight because of a maternal milk supply that does not match that infants needs? Why do they denigrate women who find their baby soothed and content after a bottle of formula, and chastise them that they should have let the baby scream instead?

Why do lactivists who have children who try to wean before their mothers have planned to stop breastfeeding counsel each other to starve the baby into submission? Why do they tell each other to offer no other source of nourishment until the baby is forced to give up his or her drive for independence and bow to the mother’s will to continue breastfeeding in order to survive?

Why do people who promote attachment parenting, which is supposed to be about meeting infant needs, to ignore their most elemental need, the need for adequate nutrition?

What’s the difference between the pediatricians of the early 20th Century who promoted feeding on schedule because of its supposed long term benefits and contemporary lactivists who ignore infant hunger because of the very small long term benefits that may or may not really exist?

It seems to me that one of the biggest ironies of all is lactivists who promote forced breastfeeding as “baby-friendly.” We already know that “baby friendly” hospital policies are definitely not mother friendly, but I suspect that such policies aren’t even baby friendly.

How could anything that ignores infant suffering be considered baby friendly?

9 Responses to “Why do lactivists think it is okay to let babies scream for hours from hunger?”

  1. realityycheque
    June 10, 2013 at 9:58 am #

    It’s interesting, on more than one occasion I have heard lactivists boast about how “African women sit around and breastfeed each other’s babies”. Nipples aren’t made in a mold; anyone who has seen a handful of female nipples will know that they can vary quite a bit. Why, I wonder, did these babies experience no ‘nipple confusion’?

  2. Miss Sadie
    June 10, 2013 at 9:13 am #

    YOUR baby might not have. Mine DID. How many hours or days should we have had to suffer to appease you?

    You tried and could… Good for you!
    I wanted to breastfeed. Tried, couldn’t, started formula… Good for me!
    Had a friend that didn’t want to, started with formula… GOOD FOR HER!

    The only people that cared were the ones that tried to make us feed bad for doing what was best FOR US AND OUR BABIES

  3. February 23, 2013 at 2:04 am #


  4. February 23, 2013 at 2:03 am #

    when I had my second child, he needed to be in the NICU a cople of days for breathing issues, I had a Doctor and a CNM she was all breastfeed him , and I was like Nothanks really I dont want to.. well since he was a bit sick I decided to go ahead and try it, The hopital put me on a HUGE double breastpump, by the time (3 or 4 days later) I could actually try to nurse him, by boobs were bigger than his head.. it was really quite comical.. so I just pumped and put it into a premie bottle for him. He would wake up and start snorting for food and I would say “hold on baby its coming” and I would start up the pump, he would hear it and settle down until I fed him. I think that he recognized the sound. LOL. A few weeks later I put him on formula, but alas, my breasts were ruined!!


  1. beneficii - October 1, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/12/why-do-lactivists-think-it-is-okay-to-let-babies-scream-for-hours-from-hunger.html […]

  2. lenovo servis - July 23, 2021

    … [Trackback]

    […] Here you can find 23247 additional Information on that Topic: skepticalob.com/2012/12/why-do-lactivists-think-it-is-okay-to-let-babies-scream-for-hours-from-hunger.html […]

  3. shopping - February 16, 2013


    […]very few sites that occur to become comprehensive beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out[…]…

  4. hair - February 15, 2013


    […]we came across a cool web-site that you simply may well appreciate. Take a search in the event you want[…]…

  5. Cyprus Photographer - February 15, 2013


    […]very few websites that take place to become detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly effectively worth checking out[…]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.